David Nowell-Smith, University of Cambridge
Abstract
Of
the many ways in which twentieth century phenomenology has had an
impact on literary criticism and the study of verse, its contribution to
the thinking of rhythm is one of the most fecund and yet least
explored. In the work of, among others, Martin Heidegger and Maurice
Merleau-Ponty, rhythm undergoes an ontologisation; that is to say, it
becomes not merely a prosodic feature of spoken language but rather a
means of thinking the auto-disclosure of beings within a world, and,
more specifically, the movement through which language first comes to
speak and sound.
Such a conception of rhythm immediately poses two problems for the study of verse itself:
1.
Does this entail a schematic separation between rhythm and prosody that
would shadow the ontico-ontological difference between beings and
being? Would this, in fact, excise rhythm from the study of verse?
2.
What happens to the status of lyric more generally? That is, if rhythm
properly speaking is taken to belong not to human speech but to
language, then is there still a place of subjective utterance and vocal
palette?
As a means of addressing these questions, I propose a
reading of the late work of the Scottish poet W.S. Graham (1918-1986).
What happens in Heidegger and Merleau-Ponty as an ontological movement
takes place in Graham as a specifically lyric predicament. That is, his
poetry probes the relation between human speech and what he calls the
language that at once shapes this speech and withdraws from it. This not
only involves a redeployment of the trope by which the poet aims to say
what is properly unsayable, but also motivates his use of verse forms
so as to capture the cadences of everyday speech, the accidental life of
human words, whilst at the same time setting up a tension between such
speech and any formulation or formalisation within verse. Through this
tension, the minutiae of words are endowed with metrical and
philosophical weight; mere accident becomes the site for the irruption
of the language into speech. It is thus that Graham offers the
possibility of an experience with the rhythms by which the language
comes to sound. The paper would aim, then, to situate, and then trace,
something like a double-rhythm within his work; both looking at the
tension between supposedly unaffected speech and metre on the one hand,
and at its tracing the movement of the language into the poems on the
other.
Bibliography
W.S. Graham, New Collected Poems (Faber, 2005)
Ralph Pite and Hester Jones (eds.), W.S. Graham: Speaking towards you (Liverpool, 2004)
Matthew Francis, Where the People Are: Language and Community in W.S. Graham (Salt, 2004)
Tony Lopez, The Poetry of W.S. Graham (Edinburgh, 1989)
Martin Heidegger, The Way to Language trans. Peter Hertz (Harper & Row, 1972)
Maurice Merleau-Ponty, La Prose du monde (Gallimard, 1969).